| |
| 1988. |
Rachel River (1987) Viveca Lindfors |
| 1989. |
1992 In the Soup (1992) Seymour Cassel |
| 1990. |
1994 Fresh (1994) Sean Nelson |
| 1991. |
1994 Fun (1994) Alicia Witt & Renee Humphrey (Special Jury Recognition for Technical Acting) |
| 1992. |
1996 I Shot Andy Warhol (1996) Lily Taylor |
| 1993. |
1997 The House of Yes (1997) Parker Posey (Special Jury Recognition for Acting) |
| 1994. |
1998 Miss Monday (1998) Andrea Hart |
| 1995. |
1999 Happy, Texas (1999) Steve Zahn (for His Comedic Acting performance) |
| 1996. |
2000 Songcatcher (2000) Janet McTeer, Aidan Quinn, Pat Carroll, Jane Adams, Greg Huge, Iris DeMent (for Outstanding Ensemble Performance) |
| 1997. |
2000 The Tao of Steve (2000) Donal Logue (for Outstanding Performance) |
| 1998. |
2001 In the Bedroom (2001) Tom Wilkinson & Sissy Spacek |
| 1999. |
2002 Manito (2002) Franky G, Leo Minaya, Manuel Cabral, Hector M. Gonzalez, Julissa Lopez, Jessica Morales, Panchito Gomez (or Ensemble Cast) |
| 2000. |
2002 Real Women Have Curves (2002) America Ferrera & Lupe Ontiveros |
| 2001. |
2003 The Station Agent (2003) Patricia Clarkson (for Outstanding Performance) |
| 2002. |
2003 Pieces of April (2003) Patricia Clarkson (for Outstanding Performance) |
| 2003. |
2003 All the Real Girls (2003) Patricia Clarkson (for Outstanding Performance) |
| 2004. |
2003 Die, Mommie, Die! (2003) Charles Busch (for Outstanding Performance) |
|
| |
| 2004. |
Down To the Bone (2004) Vera Farmiga |
| 2005. |
2005 Junebug (2005) Amy Adams |
| 2006. |
2005 Thumbsucker (2005) Lou Pucci |
| 2007. |
2006 A Guide To Recognizing Your Saints (2006) Robert Downey Jr., Shia LaBeouf, Rosario Dawson, Chazz Palminteri, Dianne Wiest, & Channing Tatum (for the Ensemble Performance) |
| 2008. |
2006 In Between Days (2006) (for Independent Vision) |
| 2009. |
2007 Teeth (2007) Jess Weixler |
| 2010. |
2007 Four Sheets To the Wind (2007) Tamara Podemski |
| 2011. |
2008 Choke (2008) Sam Rockwell, Anjelica Huston, Kelly Macdonald, & Brad William Henke (for Work by an Ensemble Cast) |
| 2012. |
2009 Precious (2009) Mo'Nique |
| 2013. |
2011 Like Crazy (2011) Felicity Jones (for Breakout Performance) |
| 2014. |
2012 The Surrogate (2012) John Hawkes, Helen Hunt, William H. Macy, Annika Marks, & Moon Bloodgood (for Ensemble Acting) |
| 2015. |
2013 The Spectacular Now (2013) Miles Teller and Shailene Woodley |
| 2016. |
2016 Morris From America (2016) Craig Robinson (for for Individual Performance) |
| 2017. |
2016 The Intervention (2016) Melanie Lynskey (for for Individual Performance) |
| 2018. |
2016 Spa Night (2016) Joe Seo (for Breakthrough Performance) |
| 2019. |
2017 Roxanne Roxanne (2017) Chante Adams (for Breakthrough Performance) |
| 2020. |
2018 Blaze (2018) Benjamin Dickey |
| 2021. |
2019 Share (2019) Rhianne Barreto |
| 2022. |
2020 Twelve (2020) Ensemble Cast |
| 2023. |
2021 Jockey (2021) Ensemble Cast |
| 2024. |
2021 On the Count of Three (2021) Clifton Collins Jr. |
| 2025. |
2022 892 (2022) Ensemble Cast |
|
|